What is Materiality?

In accounting, according to IAS 1, "materiality" refers to the importance of specific information within financial statements. Information is considered material if its absence or incorrect representation could influence the decisions made by users, such as investors or lenders. The significance of an omission or misstatement is determined by its size, nature, or both. Therefore, any error or omission that could potentially affect decision-making regarding the company is regarded as material. This concept is critical for accountants when compiling financial statements, and it is also used in auditing to ensure that information is free of significant errors or omissions to maintain the integrity of the financial statements.

Materiality in Financial Statement Compilation

Materiality is most often demonstrated as a threshold used to decide what information is important enough to be disclosed. This ensures that the financial statements remain clear and focused on significant information, avoiding the clutter of unnecessary data that doesn't impact decision-making. For instance, a small expense or revenue that does not substantially alter an investor’s view of the company's financial health might be deemed immaterial and thus will not be separately reported or disclosed.

Quantitative and Qualitative Factors

When assessing what information is important enough to include in financial reports, accountants consider both the quantity and the context or qualitative factors.

Quantitative materiality is about specific numbers—like how much revenue the company earns or its total assets—which provide clear guidelines on what counts as significant. Common benchmarks include 0.5% to 1% of total revenue, 1% to 2% of total assets, or 5% to 10% of profit before tax, but these can vary based on the industry and the specific judgment of the accountant or auditor.

Qualitative materiality factors involve the broader impact of the information, such as legal issues, potential fraud, or how the information could affect the company's reputation. This means that even if the mistake in the financial statements is small, it might still be important if it could seriously damage the company's reputation or lead to legal trouble. Therefore, deciding what's important enough to report involves looking at both the hard numbers and the overall situation to make sure the financial statements fully and accurately reflect the company's financial health.

Comparing a financial figure to the company's overall financial metrics can determine whether the item is considered quantitatively material and thus, whether it warrants specific disclosure in financial reporting to aid in decision-making processes.

Examples: Quantitative Materiality

Quantitatively Material Item

Suppose a company makes a large purchase of equipment totaling R5 million. If the company's total assets are R50 million, this purchase represents 10% of the company's total assets. Given such a significant percentage, this transaction would be considered quantitatively material. Its inclusion in financial statements is crucial because it significantly alters the asset structure and could impact decisions made by investors, creditors, or other financial stakeholders regarding the company’s asset management and capital expenditure strategies.

Quantitatively Not Material Item

Consider a company purchasing office supplies for R500. If the company’s total revenue is R10 million, this expense represents only 0.005% of total revenue. Such a small percentage is typically considered quantitatively immaterial. In this case, the cost of these supplies would likely be too insignificant to influence any economic decisions made by users of the financial statements. As a result, it would not require individual disclosure and could be grouped with other general administrative expenses in the financial reports.

Examples: Qualitative Materiality

Imagine a company involved in a legal dispute related to patent infringement that it settles for R100,000. While the settlement amount might be relatively small compared to the company’s total revenue of R50 million (only 0.2%), the nature of the settlement could have significant implications.

The settlement might indicate potential weaknesses in the company’s intellectual property rights or could set a precedent for future legal actions from other parties. Such an event might significantly impact investor confidence, stakeholder relations, and the company’s market reputation. Despite the small monetary amount, the potential for broader repercussions makes this settlement qualitatively material. It would therefore warrant specific disclosure in the financial statements to ensure that all stakeholders are aware of the incident and its possible implications on the company's future operations and legal standing.

Why Materiality is Crucial for Accountants

Accountants should consider materiality for several compelling reasons:

1. Clarity and Precision: Ensuring that the language used to describe significant transactions or events is clear and precise helps prevent misunderstandings and misinterpretations of the financial statements.

2. Effective Organisation: By organising information about significant transactions or events together, accountants can provide a coherent and logical flow of information, which aids in better understanding and analysis.

3. Appropriate Grouping: Grouping similar types of items or events appropriately helps to avoid confusion and provide a clearer picture of the company’s financial activities.

4. Avoiding Over-Detail: Separating similar items or events unnecessarily can lead to an overload of information, making the financial statements cumbersome and difficult to navigate.

5. Highlighting Key Information: By ensuring that important information is not obscured by less significant details, accountants help stakeholders focus on the most impactful data, aiding in more informed decision-making.

Assist your clients with better financial statements - enroll to CIBA’s Accountant in Practice CPD

What you will learn

Subscribing for the Bookkeepers series will enable you to:

• Be aware of the latest legislative changes and what it means for your business, practice, and your clients;

• Deliver better compliance services;

• Deliver more accurate and timely books-to-trial balance;

• Understand and apply the accounting cycle;

• Have access to your own technical resource; and

• Have access to experts for technical queries.