Asset or an expense? The art of classifying transactions
Accountants frequently encounter challenging situations where they must determine whether a transaction qualifies as an asset or should be categorised and written off as an expense. Classifying accounting transactions correctly impacts financial statement disclosures and influences strategic decision-making and regulatory compliance. The International Accounting Standards (IAS) provides the criteria to decide how to categorise transactions should be reflected in the financial statements. Below we look at the recognition criteria for assets, liabilities, expenses and revenue with relevant examples.
Achieving Fair Presentation
Fair presentation is crucial in accounting, as highlighted by the conceptual framework and Section 29 of the Companies Act of South Africa. This principle ensures that financial statements are reliable and error-free information that stakeholders can trust for decision-making. By aligning legal requirements with accounting standards, this principle enhances transparency, promotes accountability, and supports the stability of our economic environment.
Classifying Accounting Transactions
Recognising and classifying assets, liabilities, expenses, and income is fundamental in financial reporting and accounting practices, and these classifications are guided by the International Accounting Standards (IAS). Below is a detailed guide on how to recognise these elements following the IAS.
Practical Steps for Recognition:
Initial Assessment: Evaluate whether the item meets the definition of assets, liabilities, income, or expenses under IAS.
Measurement: Determine if the future economic benefits or potential outflows can be reliably quantified.
Documentation: Keep comprehensive records that detail the nature of the item and the basis for its recognition and measurement.
Review: Regularly review and reassess recognitions as per changes in circumstances.
Recognising an Asset
An asset is a resource controlled by the entity as a result of past events from which future economic benefits are expected to flow to the entity.
Step 1: Initial Assessment
Check if the transaction meets the basic definition of an asset, focusing on control, past events, and future benefits. Confirm that it is probable that economic benefits associated with the asset will flow to the entity.
Step 2: Identify the Measurable Value
Ensure that the cost or value of the asset can be measured reliably. This is either the cost or fair value of the asset at which it is recorded at in the financial statements. The accounting policy on how assets are measured should be clearly stated.
Step 3: Documentation
Document the details of the asset acquisition or creation, including costs and the basis for expecting future economic benefits.
Step 4: Regular Review
Periodically reassess the asset’s valuation and the assumptions regarding future economic benefits, especially if conditions change.
Recognising a Liability
A liability is a present obligation of the entity arising from past events, the settlement of which is expected to result in an outflow from the entity of resources embodying economic benefits.
Step 1: Initial Assessment
Determine if there is a clear obligation that results from a past event and assess the probability of an outflow of resources resulting in economic benefits.
Step 2: Identify the Measurable Value
Confirm that the amount of the liability can be estimated reliably.
Step 3: Documentation
Keep detailed records of the liability's nature, the agreement or transaction that created it, and the estimates for settlement amounts.
Step 4: Regular Review
Reevaluate the liability periodically to reflect changes in estimates, interest rates, or settlement terms.
Recognising an Income
Income is increases in economic benefits during the accounting period in the form of inflows or enhancements of assets or decreases of liabilities that result in increases in equity, other than those relating to contributions from equity participants.
Step 1: Initial Assessment
Verify that it is probable that future economic benefits associated with the income will flow to the entity.
Step 2: Evaluate Recognition Criteria
Ensure that the amount of income can be measured reliably.
Step 3: Documentation
Document the source of income, related terms, and timing of recognition based on the delivery of goods or rendering of services.
Step 4: Regular Review
Review income recognition practices, especially when there are changes in business operations or revenue recognition policies.
Recognising an Expense
Expenses are decreases in economic benefits during the accounting period in the form of outflows or depletions of assets or incurrences of liabilities that result in decreases in equity, other than those relating to distributions to equity participants.
Step 1: Initial Assessment
Determine if the transaction involves outflow or depletion of economic benefits.
Step 2: Evaluate Recognition Criteria
Matching Principle: Ensure expenses are matched with the revenues they help generate within the same period.
Measurable Cost: Confirm that the cost of the expense can be measured reliably.
Step 3: Documentation
Maintain comprehensive records of the expense, including the nature of the costs and the rationale for their period recognition.
Step 4: Regular Review
Regularly reassess expense recognition to ensure alignment with current operations and financial reporting standards.
Case Study: Recognising Financial Elements at MinexSA
MinexSA, a mining company in the Northern Cape, provides an excellent example of how to apply IAS standards in recognising assets, liabilities, income, and expenses. Below we outline the process using detailed scenarios from MinexSA's operations.
Recognising an Asset: Acquisition of a Mining License
Step 1: Initial Assessment
MinexSA has acquired a mining license for R10 million. This license gives MinexSA the control over a resource that resulted from the issuance of the license (a past event) and promises future economic benefits from the sale of extracted minerals.
Economic Benefits: Substantial revenue will probably be generated over the license's 20-year operational period.
Step 2: Identify the Measurable Value
The cost of R10 million is based on the payment made to acquire the license, providing a reliable measure of the license’s initial value.
Step 3: Documentation
Document the acquisition cost, terms of the license, and expected economic output from the minerals extracted under this license.
Step 4: Regular Review
Periodically reassess the economic output of the license and adjust the asset’s carrying amount as necessary, especially if mineral market prices fluctuate or extraction costs change.
Journal Entry:
Debit: Intangible Assets R10 million
Credit: Cash/Bank R10 million
Description: Recording the addition of the mining license as an intangible asset
Recognising a Liability: Financial Lease for Mining Equipment
Step 1: Initial Assessment
MinexSA enters a financial lease for new mining equipment valued at R15 million, incurring a clear obligation to make lease payments over a five-year term.
Outflow Probability: Regular lease payments, including principal and interest, indicate a probable outflow of economic benefits.
Step 2: Identify the Measurable Value
The total lease payments, including interest, can be estimated reliably from the lease agreement.
Step 3: Documentation
Record the nature of the lease, terms, payment schedule, and interest rate.
Step 4: Regular Review
Periodically reassess the lease liability to reflect any changes in interest rates or lease terms.
Journal Entry:
Debit: Property, Plant, and Equipment R15 million
Credit: Lease Liability R15 million
Description: Recognising the leased equipment as a fixed asset, reflecting control and future economic benefit from its use.
Recognising Income: Royalty Income from a Licensing Agreement
Step 1: Initial Assessment
MinexSA grants another company the right to extract minerals, resulting in royalties of R2 million per year, ensuring a steady inflow of cash.
Step 2: Evaluate Recognition Criteria
The royalty rate is predefined and tied to the quantity of minerals extracted, making income measurement reliable.
Step 3: Documentation
Document the licensing agreement, including the basis for royalty calculations and payment terms.
Step 4: Regular Review
Regularly assess the recognition of royalty income to ensure it aligns with the actual quantity of minerals extracted and any changes in the agreement.
Journal Entry for Recording Royalty Income:
Debit: Receivables R2 million (assuming it is to be received later)
Credit: Royalty Income R2 million
Description: Recognising royalty income to reflect the earnings from granting the license to another company for mineral extraction.
If the royalty is received at the same time as it is earned:
Debit: Cash/Bank R2 million
Credit: Royalty Income R2 million
Description: Recording the cash received as royalty income.
Recognising Expenses: Decommissioning Costs of a Mine
Step 1: Initial Assessment
Projected decommissioning costs of R50 million represent a future outflow of economic resources, linked to environmental restoration obligations.
Step 2: Evaluate Recognition Criteria
Accrue the decommissioning cost over the mine's operational life, matching it with the revenue generated.
Step 3: Documentation
Maintain detailed records of the estimated costs, basis of calculation, and any regulatory requirements influencing these estimates.
Step 4: Regular Review
Regularly update the estimated decommissioning cost based on changes in environmental regulations, technology, or operational scope.
Journal Entry for the Annual Decommissioning Cost:
Debit: Decommissioning Expense R5 million (portion of the R50 million, e.g., R5 million if distributed equally over 10 years)
Credit: Provision for Decommissioning Liability R5 million
Description: Raising the annual expense and increasing the provision for decommissioning liability for the future obligation to restore the mining site.
Prepare better financial statements with CIBA’s 2024 Accountant-In-Practice CPD Sub.
What you will learn
Subscribing to the Accountant-in-Practice series provides you access to monthly webinars covering ethics, financials, reporting, audit and assurance, working papers, law, technology, management topics, and enable you to:
Be aware of the latest legislative changes and what it means for your business, practice, and your clients;
Prepare compliant financial statements fast;
Issue reliable reports on financial statements;
Understand the laws and regulations that govern your profession; and
Develop enhanced business advisory skills.
