When Should an Accounting and Tax Practitioner Walk Away from a Client?
Introduction
For accounting and tax practitioners, maintaining strong client relationships is essential, yet there are situations when it’s in the best interest of the practitioner to walk away. Recognising the red flags early can save both reputation and legal standing of the practitioner. Below are some of the key signs that may indicate it's time to disengage from a client.
1. Lack of transparency and dishonesty
A client who withholds documents or is less than truthful about transactions can place a practitioner in a legally and ethically compromising position. For example, if a client insists on excluding certain cash transactions from records and pressures the practitioner to "adjust the figures" without evidence, it becomes clear they intend to misrepresent their financials by either inflating income or reducing the expenses from what they really are. Such behaviour is not only a red flag but also exposes the practitioner to liability for inaccuracies, and in these cases, it is prudent to consider terminating the engagement.
2. Non-compliance with regulations
Working with clients who disregard compliance obligations, such as tax filings or regulatory requirements, can create serious risks. A practitioner, for instance, may encounter a client in the scrap metal industry who continually neglects VAT returns, accumulating unpaid tax debts despite repeated guidance. In this case, the practitioner faces a dilemma: either risk association with a non-compliant client or disengage. Consistent non-compliance poses a liability for both the client and the practitioner, making termination of the engagement often the best choice.
3. Unethical or questionable business practices
When clients engage in unethical practices, such as fraud or bribery, this can endanger the practitioner’s reputation. Imagine a client who pressures the practitioner to falsify records to secure financing, promising to "correct it later." This scenario is a significant red flag, as the practitioner risks becoming complicit in potential fraud. Walking away not only protects the practitioner from legal entanglements but also safeguards their professional integrity.
4. Poor record-keeping and financial chaos
Disorganized clients with terrible record-keeping issues can be extremely challenging, hindering the practitioner’s ability to deliver accurate and timely work. For example, a client who consistently provides incomplete records, loses essential invoices, and has a chaotic financial setup shows little commitment to sound accounting practices. Despite multiple efforts to help improve the client’s processes, if no improvement is seen, it might be time to end the relationship to avoid further risk and frustration.
5. Unreasonable expectations or excessive demands
Clients who expect unreasonable turnaround times or repeatedly demand free work drain a practitioner’s resources and may not respect the professional relationship. Suppose a client regularly expects urgent work over weekends without additional fees and resists any adjustments to their fees. Even after multiple discussions, their behaviour does not change, and it becomes apparent that the practitioner is undervalued. In such cases, terminating the client relationship is necessary to protect the practitioner’s time, energy, and financial well-being.
6. Legal and ethical liability
Clients involved in activities that carry significant legal risks, such as tax evasion or money laundering, can expose practitioners to severe consequences. If a client has numerous foreign accounts and is unwilling to provide transparency, it may indicate involvement in money laundering or tax evasion schemes. Practitioners who continue such engagements risk being implicated in illegal activities themselves. The safest option in these cases is to terminate the engagement to avoid potential legal repercussions.
7. Aggressive or threatening behaviour
A client who exhibits hostile or threatening behaviour can make the working environment uncomfortable and even dangerous. Consider a client who repeatedly uses intimidation tactics, such as threatening to “take legal action” over minor billing discrepancies while withholding payment. Such clients not only make it difficult to maintain a professional working relationship but also create stress and potential reputational harm. Walking away allows the practitioner to preserve their well-being and professional peace.
Client disengagement strategy for accounting and tax practitioners
Review engagement terms and legal obligations
Engagement letter: Revisit the original engagement letter and any related documentation to confirm termination terms and obligations. This ensures that disengagement complies with any contractual conditions and outlines client’s responsibilities upon termination.
Professional obligations: Verify any ethical, professional, or regulatory requirements. For instance, some jurisdictions may require practitioners to notify clients of outstanding filing obligations or assist in the transition of services.
Assess timing and prepare for transition
Determine timing: Aim to complete any agreed-upon work to avoid disruptions for the client. For example, if a major tax filing is pending, clarify how and when this responsibility will be transferred.
Prepare documents: Gather and organise essential documents, records, and notes to ensure a smooth handover. This includes finalised working papers, tax returns filed, and any outstanding reports.
Draft a formal termination letter
State the decision clearly: In a direct, professional manner, state that you are terminating the engagement.
Summarise key reasons: Provide a concise and factual summary of reasons for termination (e.g., lack of transparency, non-compliance, or unprofessional behaviour). Avoid inflammatory language.
Specify effective date: Clearly state the termination date to avoid ambiguity.
Outline transition and final steps: Explain any final actions you will take and steps for a smooth transition. For example, indicate that you will transfer files and documents to a successor accountant if appointed by the client.
Arrange for the transfer of records and handover
Client instructions: Request the client’s instructions for transferring documents to a new practitioner.
Outline delivery terms: State if there are any delivery terms, such as a timeline for file transfer or specific costs if courier services are needed.
Finalise invoicing and settlement of any outstanding payments
Final invoice: Issue a final invoice covering completed work up to the termination date, including any outstanding charges.
Payment terms: Clearly state the due date for this final payment and consider providing payment options to facilitate closure.
Document and archive the termination process
Internal record-keeping: Document all communications related to the termination. This includes copies of emails, the termination letter, and any correspondence about outstanding work.
Archive client files: Ensure compliance with data retention regulations by securely archiving client files as per your firm’s document retention policies.
Concluding thoughts
Recognising these red flags early on can help CIBA members decide when it is time to step back from a client relationship. From ongoing non-compliance and aggressive behaviour to unreasonable demands and questionable ethics, certain scenarios necessitate a careful, professional disengagement. Developing a clear termination strategy such as providing a formal letter and documenting the decision can help ensure a smooth transition and uphold the practitioner’s integrity, reputation, and peace of mind. The strategy offers a respectful, professional exit that minimizes disruption for the client while protecting the practitioner’s reputation and fulfilling all professional obligations.
Example of wording for the termination letter:
Dear [Client's Name],
After careful consideration, I have decided to conclude our professional engagement, effective [Termination Date].
This decision is based on [reason, such as 'repeated non-compliance with tax regulations’].
I will complete any pending work as outlined in our engagement letter until the effective termination date.
To facilitate a smooth transition, please let us know how you would like to handle the transfer of your records.
Sincerely,
[Your Name]
Join us for the CIBA Annual Practice Management Conference 2024 here.
🌟 Join Us for the CIBA Annual Practice Management Conference 2024 🌟
Accounting and tax pros, mark your calendars. The CIBA Practice Management Conference is back with a two-day powerhouse experience that’s packed with insights, networking, and the roadmap to level up your practice.🚀
What’s the Deal?
🗓️ Day 1: November 7, 2024
In-Person, at Regenesys Campus, Sandton – It's all about the sectors your clients operate in. From law to tech, agriculture to medical, we’re diving deep into the latest trends to make you the MVP for your clients.
🍸 Wrap up the day with a cocktail party and network with industry peers.
🗓️ Day 2: November 8, 2024
Join us online to focus on the regs. Get the lowdown from top regulators like SARS Commissioner Edward Kieswetter and experts from the FSCA and FIC. It’s everything you need to tackle compliance with confidence. 💻
Why Attend?
🔍 Unlock Sector Secrets: Discover new ways to support clients in key sectors.
💡 Navigate Compliance: Get the latest on CIPC, NLC requirements, and the SME Launch.
📈 Earn CPD Points: Grab 10 CPD points while gaining valuable knowledge.
🎟️ All this for R875 – VAT Included That’s your ticket to a smarter, future-ready practice.