$1.8 Billion Accounting Error – A Wake-Up Call for Public Finance Oversight

This article will count 0.25 units (15 minutes) of unverifiable CPD. Remember to log these units under your membership profile.

In a rare move, the South Carolina Senate has voted to remove the state’s Treasurer, Curtis Loftis, from office over a staggering $1.8 billion accounting error — all stemming from years of unbalanced books during a system change. While no actual money went missing, poor accounting practices, a lack of oversight, and failure to report errors led to what’s now called one of the biggest administrative breakdowns in the state's financial history.

How Did It Go Wrong?

• Faulty System Transition
  A decade ago, South Carolina moved to a new accounting system. Thousands of accounts were transferred, but mismatches between old and new system formats were never properly resolved.

• Errors Stacked Up
  Instead of correcting the mismatches, the state kept shifting the differences into a “plug account” every year. This snowballed into a false balance of $1.8 billion over time.

• Triggered by a Separate Mistake
  The issue came to light after a $3.5 billion overstatement in university funding. That blunder led to a deeper investigation which uncovered the long-standing accounting error.

• Forensic Accountants Called In
  The state spent millions on forensic audits, which confirmed the so-called funds were not real cash—just accumulated accounting errors.

• Lack of Accountability
  Treasurer Curtis Loftis never reported the issue to lawmakers. He denied responsibility, blaming others, which the Senate saw as a serious failure in leadership.

• Senate Vote for Removal
  The Senate found Loftis guilty of willful neglect and voted to remove him. The House will now decide whether to confirm his dismissal — a rare action in the state’s history.

An Important Lesson for Us

This case is a clear reminder of how crucial strong financial governance, accountability, and transparent reporting are in the public sector — and the potential consequences when they’re missing. Forensic accountants were called in to untangle the decade-old errors, costing millions in auditing fees. The saga underscores the importance of ongoing reconciliations, proper change management when transitioning financial systems, and taking responsibility when mistakes arise.

Accountants advising government entities or involved in financial system changes should take note: robust internal controls and timely reporting aren’t optional — they’re essential to public trust and institutional credibility.